AI-generated illustration
Three things to remember
- NAV represents net asset value per unit, not an independent cheapness score.
- Equal amounts earning equal percentage returns produce equal values, despite different unit counts.
- Assess an NFO through mandate, need, risk and cost rather than its ₹10 headline.
A new fund offers units at ₹10 while an existing scheme has a NAV of ₹100. Will buying the new fund produce ten times the benefit? You will receive ten times as many units for the same amount, but that does not establish a larger investment value or future return. Confusing a per-unit number with the valuation of the underlying assets is a common mistake.
What does a unit represent?
In simplified form, NAV equals the scheme’s assets minus liabilities, divided by outstanding units. It measures each unit’s share of net assets. AMFI’s investor explanation describes this basis. Source: AMFI NAV calculation.
Cutting a cake into ten pieces rather than a hundred does not change the cake’s size. The analogy does not explain investment risk, but it helps expose the unit-count mistake. A ₹100 unit can represent a larger slice than a ₹10 unit. Different schemes also own different assets, so they should not literally be assumed to be identical cakes.
Invest the same ₹10,000
Assume hypothetical Fund A has a ₹10 NAV and Fund B has a ₹100 NAV. You invest ₹10,000 in each, ignoring stamp duty, other levies, rounding, exit loads and taxes. Both subsequently experience the same 10% NAV growth.
| Item | Fund A | Fund B |
|---|---|---|
| Initial NAV | ₹10 | ₹100 |
| Units | 1,000 | 100 |
| NAV after 10% growth | ₹11 | ₹110 |
| Total value | ₹11,000 | ₹11,000 |
Fund A’s NAV rose only ₹1 and Fund B’s rose ₹10, but the percentage and rupee gains are identical: ₹1,000. If both instead fall 10%, NAVs become ₹9 and ₹90 and both investments are worth ₹9,000. A lower starting NAV offers no protection from that loss.
Why an NFO is not automatically a bargain
An NFO’s initial offer price is specified in its scheme documents. That price does not automatically let the fund buy securities at a market discount. AMFI’s myths-and-facts material explicitly addresses the mistake of treating a low NAV or a new ₹10 fund as cheaper. Source: AMFI myths and facts.
A new scheme may offer a useful strategy, but “new” is not automatically good or bad. Without its own live record, understanding the proposed mandate and process becomes particularly important. Strong returns from another scheme managed by the same AMC are not this scheme’s performance history.
What should be compared?
- Purpose: does the strategy meet a need that the existing portfolio does not already cover?
- Underlying risk: identify equity, debt, concentration, liquidity or interest-rate exposure.
- Mandate: understand which assets the scheme may hold and the relevant limits.
- Costs and choices: examine the plan, expense disclosures and exit conditions.
- Comparable alternatives: compare similar categories and objectives, not just the highest recent return.
SEBI’s investor guidance puts goals, time horizon and risk appetite among the foundations of an investment decision. Source: SEBI. A high or low NAV does not answer those questions.
Why NAV still matters
NAV helps track the value of a unit over time within the same fund and option. It also helps estimate the value of your units. But distributions, option changes and investor cash flows mean two NAV figures may not describe the entire personal return. Raw NAV comparisons between Growth and IDCW options can be misleading.
Units multiplied by applicable NAV give an indicative holding value. Actual redemption proceeds may involve relevant exit loads, taxes or other adjustments. Keep the displayed value separate from the net amount ultimately received.
When looking at a fund screen, write down what each number answers. NAV answers a per-unit valuation question; units answer ownership quantity; their product estimates total value. None alone establishes whether the investment suits the goal.
Frequently asked questions
Is receiving more units an advantage?
Not by itself. The percentage change in the total investment and the net outcome matter.
Does a high NAV mean there is little room to grow?
No. ₹100 to ₹110 and ₹10 to ₹11 are both 10% changes. Future outcomes depend on the underlying portfolio.
Should every NFO be avoided?
No blanket conclusion follows. Assess genuine portfolio need, strategy and alternatives, rather than choosing it because of ₹10.
Takeaway
A fund’s quality is not hidden in its unit’s sticker price. Move beyond the appeal of more units and examine purpose, risk and cost.
Educational information, not a personalised fund recommendation. Examples are hypothetical. Sources checked on 5 November 2026.
Discussion / Comments
All Comments
No published comments yet.