Same Nifty 50 TRI. Same ₹10 lakh invested. Yet a ₹1,200 gap after one year. To 31 July 2026, both index funds and their benchmark fell, but not by the same amount. Even the fund that fell less lagged the index.
We compare the Regular Growth plans of UTI and HDFC over the same dates, then explain tracking difference, tracking error and what to check before switching.
What happened to ₹10 lakh?
| Investment or benchmark | One-year return | Ending value* |
|---|---|---|
| Nifty 50 TRI | −0.43% | ₹9,95,700 |
| UTI Nifty 50 Index Fund | −0.72% | ₹9,92,800 |
| HDFC Nifty 50 Index Fund | −0.84% | ₹9,91,600 |
*Both funds are Regular Plan – Growth. Values use the AMCs’ published returns rounded to two decimal places, with no deposits or withdrawals. Personal tax and any applicable exit load are excluded. The TRI is a benchmark, not a product you can buy directly. Sources: HDFC factsheet and UTI factsheet.
Subtract the benchmark return from the fund return: UTI lagged by 0.29 percentage points and HDFC by 0.41 percentage points. The funds differed by 0.12 percentage points, or ₹1,200 on ₹10 lakh. This is a one-year observation, not a forecast of next year’s ranking.
Confirm what you are comparing
Nifty 50, Nifty Next 50 and a factor-based index may have familiar names but different exposures. A price index also differs from a Total Return Index, which includes the effect of reinvested distributions. Comparing a fund with the wrong benchmark makes the exercise misleading from the start.
Next identify direct versus regular plans and growth versus IDCW options. Different options or periods can explain gaps unrelated to replication quality. A screenshot dated 30 September and one dated 28 October are not matched observations. Your personal SIP XIRR is also not the same measure as the factsheet’s point-to-point lump-sum return.
Tracking error answers a different question
One fund could trail its benchmark by a small, relatively consistent amount. Its gap can remain present while varying little. Another may alternate between slightly ahead and slightly behind. It could finish with a small total gap despite a more variable path.
An official AMC explanation distinguishes the return gap from tracking error, the annualised standard deviation of periodic return differences. Do not substitute one measure for the other. The one-year return table above does not provide enough information to calculate daily tracking error; a periodic return series is required. Source: DSP tracking explanation.
Why can the implementation differ?
A fund pays expenses. Cash may remain between receiving inflows and buying securities. Redemptions can require sales. When an index changes constituents, execution timing and prices can differ. Corporate actions and matching exact portfolio weights involve operational work rather than merely copying a spreadsheet.
A SEBI-hosted scheme information document identifies these kinds of factors under tracking risk. It describes a particular scheme and is cited here to explain the mechanism, not to endorse that investment. Without relevant fund data, do not invent how many basis points each factor contributed. Source: 2026 scheme document, tracking-risk section.
A practical comparison process
- Record the exact benchmark TRI and matching plan and option.
- Use the same end date and measurement periods, looking at both shorter and longer records.
- Check the sign convention for tracking difference before interpreting a positive number.
- Read the frequency, annualisation method and available history for tracking error.
- Examine BER/TER labels, exit conditions and operational convenience separately.
- Assess consistency rather than selecting a winner from one isolated month.
AMFI provides a disclosure interface for tracking error and tracking difference. Select the latest available date and do not interpret missing history as zero error. A new scheme’s brief record is not equivalent evidence to an established fund’s longer record. Source: AMFI tracking disclosures.
Keep the size of the difference in perspective without dismissing it. A recurring small gap can matter on a large balance over many years. But an unnecessary switch can introduce costs of its own. Those are separate calculations from identifying which fund tracked more closely during a past period.
Three common questions
Can an index fund finish ahead of its benchmark?
Yes, the gap can be positive over some periods. That does not establish permanent active outperformance. Check the reason and the measurement period.
Does low tracking error protect against losses?
No. A fund that closely follows a falling index can also fall. This measures closeness to the benchmark, not market safety.
Should I switch immediately over the ₹1,200 gap?
No. First consider persistence, your investment size, potential taxes and exit loads, and switching friction. The example is not a decision threshold.
The takeaway
The same index name does not guarantee identical investor outcomes. A useful comparison combines matched data, the return gap, variability of that gap and real costs.
Do not subtract TER again: published fund returns based on NAV already reflect fund expenses. Fees are useful to compare, but the factsheet does not show how much of this historical gap they caused.
Educational information, not personalised investment advice. This historical example uses the published July 2026 factsheets. Past performance does not guarantee future returns.
चर्चा / Comments