Retirement SWP illustration. Increasing the initial ₹40,000 withdrawal changes how long the money can last. AI-generated illustration.
You start with ₹1 crore and withdraw ₹40,000 a month. Is there money left after 30 years, or does the portfolio run out? In our smooth 4% example, a fixed ₹40,000 withdrawal leaves around ₹50 lakh after 30 years. Raise that withdrawal by 6% each year, and even a smooth 8% return runs out in year 28. And a big loss near the start can undo the benefit of a respectable long-term return.
Start with two separate questions. How much do you need to spend each month? And how fast does that amount need to rise to buy the same things later? We model both. Then we use the actual NAVs of a large-cap, mid-cap, small-cap and flexi-cap scheme to see what happens when returns do not arrive in a straight line.
What remains at 12%, 15% and 18%?
Monthly withdrawals of ₹40,000 total ₹4.80 lakh in the first year. That is 4.8% of your starting balance, not a guaranteed or safe withdrawal rate. Each withdrawal happens at month-end. One version holds it at ₹40,000 throughout. The other increases it once every 12 months: to ₹42,400 in year two, ₹44,944 in year three, and so on.
| Constant annual return | 10 years, fixed | 20 years, fixed | 30 years, fixed | 30 years, 6% annual withdrawal increase |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12% | 2.22 | 6.00 | 17.75 | 9.54 |
| 15% | 3.01 | 11.12 | 43.95 | 31.80 |
| 18% | 4.01 | 19.79 | 102.37 | 83.91 |
Those large balances say more about three decades of uninterrupted compounding than about what a retiree should expect. The model applies a smooth monthly equivalent of the annual return. It never has a bad year unless we deliberately put one in. The final balances are in future rupees, not today’s purchasing power. Personal taxes, exit loads and other transaction charges are not deducted. Treat 12%, 15% and 18% as illustrations, not forecasts or planning floors.
Fixed income on paper, a shrinking budget in practice
At 6% inflation, ₹40,000 in year 30 buys what about ₹7,382 bought in year one. If you lift the withdrawal by 6% each year instead, the year-30 amount reaches roughly ₹2.17 lakh a month. The total scheduled withdrawals are then about ₹3.79 crore, versus ₹1.44 crore with fixed withdrawals, assuming the money lasts for all 30 years.
| Annual return | Fixed ₹40,000: 30-year balance | Withdrawals rise 6% a year |
|---|---|---|
| 4% | ₹50 lakh left | First shortfall in year 19, month 1 |
| 6% | ₹1.85 crore left | First shortfall in year 22, month 6 |
| 8% | ₹4.43 crore left | First shortfall in year 28, month 7 |
Household inflation is not uniform. Rent, medical bills, travel and groceries do not all rise at the same rate. The 6% assumption gives us a common test, not a prediction. Think about which costs you must cover even in a bad market and which you could delay or pay from another income source.
What actual NAVs show across four equity categories
All four examples use HDFC Direct Plan – Growth funds. They are examples from one fund house, not category averages or a selection of winners. Each starts with a hypothetical ₹1 crore holding on 28 October 2016. The first withdrawal is on 30 November 2016, and the 120th on 30 October 2026, using the last available weekday NAV of each month. Fixed withdrawals total ₹48 lakh; withdrawals rising 6% a year total about ₹63.27 lakh. These are simulations on historical prices, not actual investor accounts or 30-year forecasts.
| Category / scheme | NAV CAGR | Final balance: fixed | Final balance: 6% increase |
|---|---|---|---|
| Large cap HDFC Large Cap Fund | 11.81% | ₹2.19 crore | ₹1.98 crore |
| Mid cap HDFC Mid Cap Fund | 16.31% | ₹3.30 crore | ₹3.03 crore |
| Small cap HDFC Small Cap Fund | 16.39% | ₹3.44 crore | ₹3.20 crore |
| Flexi cap HDFC Flexi Cap Fund | 15.31% | ₹3.03 crore | ₹2.78 crore |
Ending balances hide the difficult months. In March 2020 the four fixed-withdrawal examples hit their lowest recorded month-end balances: ₹81.89 lakh in large cap, ₹74.58 lakh in mid cap, ₹75.15 lakh in small cap and ₹79.37 lakh in flexi cap. These are balances after that month’s withdrawal, not intramonth lows.
The ten-year NAV CAGR uses the opening and closing NAV with no withdrawals. Published NAV already reflects ongoing scheme expenses. The simulation does not deduct investor taxes, exit loads, STT or other transaction charges. Labels are current. At the start, today’s HDFC Small Cap Fund was HDFC Small and Mid-Cap Fund. Its name and investment mandate changed on 9 November 2016. It is therefore not a decade of the same small-cap mandate. This period shows what happened in four examples, not which category is preferable for retirement.
Scheme NAV codes: HDFC Large Cap Fund: 119018; HDFC Mid Cap Fund: 118989; HDFC Small Cap Fund: 130503; HDFC Flexi Cap Fund: 118955. HDFC Mutual Fund NAV list.
An SWP sells units to send you a fixed amount. At a NAV of ₹100, a ₹40,000 payout takes 400 units. At a NAV of ₹70, it takes about 571.43 units, or 43% more units. When the price recovers, only the remaining units benefit. This is why the fund’s published annualised return cannot tell you what happened to an investor withdrawing every month.
Same CAGR, very different outcomes
Consider two hypothetical 30-year sequences. Each has 29 years of +12% and one year of −30%. In one, the loss happens first. In the other, it happens in the final year. With no withdrawals, both turn ₹1 crore into about ₹18.72 crore, a 10.26% CAGR.
- Crash in year one: Starting at ₹40,000 a month and increasing the withdrawal by 6% every year, the account cannot make the full scheduled withdrawal in month four of year 26.
- The same crash in year 30: All scheduled withdrawals go through and about ₹5.91 crore remains.
This is a demonstration of the order of returns, not a backtest of any fund. Within each model year, the return compounds at an even monthly rate. A real sell-off can be concentrated in a few weeks, with very different recovery timing. The ₹5.91 crore is also a nominal value at the end of the model, not an amount you could spend today.
Four checks before relying on an SWP in retirement
- Separate essential expenses from flexible ones. Write down housing, health care and regular bills first. Identify expenses you could postpone following a market loss.
- Subtract reliable outside income. If you receive a pension or other recurring income, calculate the remaining gap. Use the amount available to spend after taxes, not merely the redemption amount.
- Test a loss at the start. Run lower returns, faster inflation and an early loss together. Consider what keeping essential near-term spending in a separate cash or lower-volatility reserve would change.
- Decide when to review withdrawals. Know whether you could pause an annual increase after a bad year. Avoid choosing a fund just because it finishes with the highest balance in one historical window.
Bottom line: ₹1 crore and ₹40,000 alone do not give your SWP an expiry date. The pace of spending increases and the timing of market losses can change the result by years. Before planning around the attractive 12%, 15% or 18% rows, test your spending against 4%, 6% and 8% returns and an early crash.
Sources and calculation method
- AMFI historical NAV files
- SEBI mutual fund scheme categories
- Scheme document hosted by SEBI: how fixed-amount SWP redemptions work
Data used for the simulation: The monthly series came from a NAV data mirror. All four NAVs at six checkpoints (start, first withdrawal, December 2018, March 2020, December 2025, and final withdrawal) matched the official AMFI archive: 24 values checked. AMFI starting-date record · NAV data mirror, example.
In the smooth scenarios, monthly return = (1 + annual return)1/12 − 1. Apply the monthly change first, then redeem the planned amount. Where modelled, the payout increases after each block of 12 months. The exhaustion date is the first month the full scheduled amount cannot be redeemed. This is educational analysis. Past performance does not guarantee future returns.
चर्चा / Comments